본문 바로가기
HOME> 논문 > 논문 검색상세

논문 상세정보

경관선호와 평가에 있어서 개인적 차이 및 유사성에 대한 이해와 그 중요성에 관한 고찰
Review on Individual Differences and Similarities in Landscape Preference and Evaluation

이영경    (동국대학교 조경학과  );
  • 초록

    This paper reviews and examines the empirical results of past research concerning individual differences and similarities in landscape preference and evaluation. The conflicting results (differences and similarities) found in the review are attributed to the variety of methodology adopted by the past research and to the lack of comprehensive theoretical base in the field of landscape research. Two suggestions are derived from the review. First, both the landscape type to be evaluated and the measurement context to be used by research subjects have critical importance in results. Thus, it is suggested that researchers should be careful in selecting landscape type and measurement tool. Second, more scholartic endeavours should be put into a development of comprehensive theory of landscape experience that could explain both differences and similarities in people's landscape preference and evaluation. Once developed, the theory would not only provide us more valid and specific research methodology, but also allow us to design more healthy and valued landscape.


  • 참고문헌 (54)

    1. Does post-modernism communicate? , Groat,L.;D.Canter , Progressive Architecture / v.12,pp.84-87,
    2. Kaplan,S.;R.Kaplan , Humanscape : Environement for people / v.,pp.,
    3. influence of passive experiences with plants on individual well-being and health , Ulrich,R.;R.Parsons , Paper presented at the national Symposium on the Role of Horticulture in Human Well-Being and Social Development / v.,pp.,
    4. Estimating psychological hostility from damages forest stands , Buhyoff,G.L.;W.A.leuschner , Forest Science / v.24,pp.424-432,
    5. Landscape perception: research, application and theory , Zube,E.H.;J.L.Sell;J.L.Taylor , Landscape Planning / v.9,pp.1-33,
    6. Building imagery : a comparative study of environmental cognition , Verderber,S.;G.T.Moore , Man Environment System / v.7,pp.332-341,
    7. 택리지의 경관론적 고찰:복거총론 「산수」를 중심으로 , 정기호 , 한국조경학회지 / v.21,pp.1-10,
         
    8. Landscape preference: an international replication , Shafer,E.L.;M.Tooby , Leisure Research / v.60-65,pp.,
    9. A sutudy of meaning and architecture , Hershberger,R.G. , In EDRA 1 Proceedings of the First Annual Environmental Design Research Association Conference / v.,pp.,
    10. Craik,K.H. , A System of Landscape Dimensions: Appraisale of its Objectivity and Illustration of its Scientific Application / v.,pp.,
    11. Comments , Simon,H.A.;M.S.Clark(ed.);S.T.Fiske(ed.) , Affect and Cognition / v.,pp.,
    12. Berlyne,D.E. , Aesthetics and Psychobiology / v.,pp.,
    13. Dewey,J. , Art as experience / v.,pp.,
    14. An ecological and evolutionary approach to landscape aesthetics , Orians,G.;Penning-Roswell,E.C.(ed.);Lowenthal(ed.) , Landscape Meaning and Values / v.,pp.,
    15. Finding valued landscapes , Lowenthal,D. , Progressive Human Geography / v.2,pp.373-418,
    16. A landscape architects' interpretation of people's landscape preferences , Buhuoff,G.L.;J.D.Wellman;H.Harvey;R.A.Fraser , Journal of Leisure Reseach / v.12,pp.257-272,
    17. The influence of the socio-economic background of subjects on their landscape preference evalution , Tips,W.E.J.;T.Savasdisara , Landscape and Urban Planning / v.13,pp.225-230,
    18. The beauty and the beast: some preliminary comparisons of 'high' versus'popular' resiedntial architecture and public versus architect judgments of same , Devlin,K.;J.L.Nasar , Journal of Environmental Psychology / v.9,pp.333-344,
    19. The physical environment: a problem for a psychology of stimulation , Wohlwill,J.F. , Journal of Social Issues / v.ⅩⅩⅱ,pp.29-38,
    20. Studies in the New Experimental Aesthetics:Steps Toward an Objective Psychology of Aesthetic Appreciation , Berlyne,D.E.;Berlyne,D.E.(ed.) , New experimantal asethetics / v.,pp.,
    21. Csikszentmihalyi,M.;E.Rochberg-Halton , The Meaning of Things: Domestic Symbols and the Self / v.,pp.,
    22. Landscape perception: an examination and empirical investigation of two central issue in the area , Purcell,A.T.;R.J.Lamb , Journal of Environmental Management / v.19,pp.31-63,
    23. 경관의 미학적 경험에 있어서 감정과 인지의 상호작용 , 이영경 , 한국조경학회지 / v.20,pp.11-20,
    24. Cognitive maps, human needs and the designed environment , Kaplan,S;W.F.E.Presier(ed.) , Environmental Design Research(EDRA 4) / v.,pp.,
    25. The concept of nature: a psychologist's view , Wohlwill,J.F.;I.Altman(ed.);J.F.Wohlwill(ed.) , Human Behavior and Environment / v.,pp.,
    26. Social cognition and affect , Fiske,S.T.;Harvey,J.H.(ed.) , Cognition, Social Behavior, and the Environment,Hillsdale / v.,pp.,
    27. Environmental perceptions and adaptation level in the Arctic , Sonnenfeld,J.;D.lowenthal(ed.) , Environmental perception and Behavior / v.,pp.,
    28. Yi,Y.K. , Affect and Cognition Interface in aesthetic Experiences of Landscape / v.,pp.,
    29. Cross-cultural comparisons of landscape scenic beauty evaluations: a case study in Bali , Hull,R.B.Ⅳ.;G.R.Revell , Journal of Environmental psychology / v.19,pp.1-15,
    30. Themes in landscape assessment theory , Zube,E.H. , Landscape Journal / v.3,pp.104-110,
    31. Aesthetics, affect, & cognition: environmental preference from an evolutinary perspective , Kaplan,S. , Environment and Behavior / v.19,pp.3-32,
    32. Feeling and Thinking: preferences need no inferences , Zajonc,R.B. , American Psychology / v.35,pp.151-175,
    33. The influence of the environmental background of subjects on their landscape preference evaluation , Tips,W.E.J.;T.Savasdisara , Landscape and Urban Planning / v.13,pp.125-133,
    34. Landscape preference metrics: an international comparison , Buhyoff,G.L.;J.D.Wellman;N.E.Kock;L.Gauthier;S.Hultman , Journal of Environmental Management / v.16,pp.181-190,
    35. Environmental psychology , Stokols,D. , Annual Review of Psychology / v.29,pp.253-295,
    36. Appleton,J. , The Experience of landscape / v.,pp.,
    37. Environmental aesthetics: the environment as a source of affect , Wohlwill,J.F.;I.Altman(ed.);J.Wohlwill(ed.) , Human Behavior and the Environment / v.,pp.,
    38. Rating everyday rural landscapes of the Northeastern U.S , Zube,E.H. , Landscape Architecture / v.63,pp.370-376,
    39. Cross-cultural explorations in landscape perception , Zube,E.H.;L.V.Mills;E.H.Zube(ed.) , Studies in Landscape Perception / v.,pp.,
    40. Brunswick,E. , Preception and the Representative Design of Psychological Experiments / v.,pp.,
    41. Orians,G. , Habitat Selection : General Theory and Application to Human Behavior in the Evolution and Human Behavior / v.,pp.,
    42. Cross-disciplinary and inter mode agreement on the description and evaluation of landscape resources , Zube,E.H. , Environment and Behavior / v.6,pp.69-89,
    43. Mandler,G. , Mind and Body : Psychology of Emotion and Stress / v.,pp.,
    44. Cross-cultural perceptions of scenic and heritage landscapes , Zube,E.H.;O.G.Pitt , Landscape Planning / v.8,pp.69-87,
    45. Kelly,G. , The Psychology of personal Construct / v.,pp.,
    46. Segall,M.H.;D.T.Campell;M.J.Herskovits , The influence of Culture on Visual Perception / v.,pp.,
    47. Development of visual preference for natural environment , Balling,J.D.;J.H.Falk , Environment and Behavior / v.14,pp.5-28,
    48. Environmental peroeption and affect:a schema discrepancy model , Purcell,A.T. , Environment and Behavior / v.18,pp.3-30,
    49. Visual landscape and psychological well-being , Ulrich,R. , Landscape Research / v.4,pp.17-23,
    50. Meaning in post-modernism arshitecture: an examination using multiple sorting task , Groat,L. , Journal of Environmental Psychology / v.3,pp.22,
    51. Methodological issues in the assessment of landscape quality , Daniel,T.;J.Vining;I.Altman(ed.);J.Wohlwill(ed.) , Human Behavior and Environment / v.6,pp.39-84,
    52. A model of person-environment compatibility , Kaplan,S. , Environment and Behavior / v.15,pp.311-333,
    53. Aesthetic and affective responses to natural environments , Ulrich,R.;I.Altman(ed.);J.F.Wohlwill(ed.) , Behavior and Natural Environment / v.6,pp.85-125,
    54. Natural landscape preference: a predictive model , Zube,E.H.;D.G.Pitt;E.A.Schmidt , Journal of Leisure Research / v.1,pp.1-19,
  • 이 논문을 인용한 문헌 (11)

    1. 1995. "A Cross-cultural Comparisons for Landscape Preference on Korean Traditional Garden" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture, 23(2): 104~112     
    2. 1996. "A Study on the Visual Character and Preference of Roadscape -In Case of the Main Entrance Road in Chongju-" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture, 24(1): 15~31     
    3. 1997. "A Visual Preference Study on Namdaemun and its Surroundings Using Visual Simulation Techniques" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture, 25(3): 12~24     
    4. 1997. "The effect of landscape meaning on landscape assessment focused on the interaction with scenic beauty, people\\`s purpose and socio-cultural experience" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture, 24(4): 59~73     
    5. 1998. "" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture, 26(3): 52~65     
    6. 1998. "The Image and Visual Preference for Urban Setting : Focused on Outdoor Spaces of Urban Office Buildings" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture, 26(3): 134~142     
    7. 1999. "The Influence of the Landscape Meaning Illustrated to Subjects on their Landscape Preference" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture, 26(4): 14~24     
    8. 2000. "Domestic and Foreign Trends in the Study of the Landscape Evaluation" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture, 28(2): 49~60     
    9. 2002. "Viewers' Visual Preferences of Seasonal Landscape" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture, 30(4): 19~27     
    10. 2003. "Factor Analysis and LISREL Model Development for Landscape Estimation on The Road Cutting Slope Area" 大韓交通學會誌 = Journal of Korean Society of Transportation, 21(2): 33~43     
    11. 2004. "Characteristic Analysis of Natural Landscape: Based on the Assessments of Naturalness by Landscape Professionals and Laypersons" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture, 31(6): 1~14     

 저자의 다른 논문

  • 이영경 (21)

    1. 1996 "환경영향평가 주민참여의 제도적 문제점과 내용분석" 환경영향평가 = Journal of environmental impact assessment 5 (1): 1~13    
    2. 1997 "환경영향평가서 영향예측에 대한 연구" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture 25 (3): 89~100    
    3. 1997 "경관의 의미와 경관평가에 관한 연구 - 경관의 미적 특질, 사람들의 목적 및 사회 문화적 경험과의 관련성을 중심으로 -" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture 24 (4): 59~73    
    4. 1997 "환경영향평가서 저감방안의 실효성에 대한 연구: 내용분석을 중심으로" 환경영향평가 = Journal of environmental impact assessment 6 (2): 165~180    
    5. 2000 "경관영향평가서의 실효성 평가 -경관영향평가서와 환경영향평가서의 내용분석을 중심으로-" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture 27 (5): 66~79    
    6. 2000 "도시림의 식생구조분석 -경주 남산을 중심으로-" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture 28 (3): 13~24    
    7. 2000 "경주 황성공원의 식생구조 및 관리방안" 한국환경생태학회지 = Korean journal of environment and ecology 14 (1): 46~56    
    8. 2004 "자연경관의 특질 분석 : 자연성에 대한 조경 전문가와 일반인의 평가를 중심으로" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture 31 (6): 1~14    
    9. 2004 "한국조경학회지 게재논문 환경심리분야의 연구경향" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture 32 (1): 157~169    
    10. 2006 "경관의 치유적 특질이 관광지 방문 선호 및 만족에 미치는 영향 - 경주 유산경관에 대한 미국인의 평가를 중심으로 -" 한국조경학회지 = Journal of Korean institute of landscape architecture 34 (5): 1~13    

 활용도 분석

  • 상세보기

    amChart 영역
  • 원문보기

    amChart 영역

원문보기

무료다운로드
  • NDSL :
유료다운로드

유료 다운로드의 경우 해당 사이트의 정책에 따라 신규 회원가입, 로그인, 유료 구매 등이 필요할 수 있습니다. 해당 사이트에서 발생하는 귀하의 모든 정보활동은 NDSL의 서비스 정책과 무관합니다.

원문복사신청을 하시면, 일부 해외 인쇄학술지의 경우 외국학술지지원센터(FRIC)에서
무료 원문복사 서비스를 제공합니다.

NDSL에서는 해당 원문을 복사서비스하고 있습니다. 위의 원문복사신청 또는 장바구니 담기를 통하여 원문복사서비스 이용이 가능합니다.

이 논문과 함께 이용한 콘텐츠
이 논문과 함께 출판된 논문 + 더보기